any suggestions? Both do in some way, but are not necessary in a healthy, cycled aquarium. SEACHEM Purigen® is a premium synthetic adsorbent. If you are cycling, it will probably slow things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted. Water Chemistry . I am particular about what I wish to view in my tank's with respect to clarity and have seen no negative effect from using the Purigen BUT,, I also add dry fertilizer's in the form of inorganic mineral salt's. Come join the discussion about flora, fauna, health, housing, filters, care, classifieds, and more! I have one tank 80 U.S. gallon's that ran for a year heavily planted without the use of Purigen. Share: Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link. Since I already have a bag of purigen, I might as well use it in the tank that I use Prime. Jan 17, 2019. It is based on my experience and a pH crash in a small tank that was duplicated and verified by Seachem, causing a change to the product label and me getting a bunch of free stuff. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. The Ista CO2 Diffuser Set is a simple way to supply Carbon Dioxide to your planted tank. Thread starter Christian ... That purigen or activated carbon removes impurities from the water is a much more important factor and that will have a greater impact on the health of the fish that getting tannins from peat. I'm no bleach expert and all I could find was I have been using Seachem Purigen on my planted tanks and saltwater tanks that I maintain for others. I have now started my first properly planted tank and my logic tells me that purigen and carbon might remove fertilizer from the water column, so I decided against using these products in my canister for the planted aquarium. This article describes my personal method for recharging the product. Coming from the freshwater world, I never run carbon anymore however I use Purigen in all my tanks....I find it rivals over carbon both in efficiency and lifespan. Carbons made from coconut shell and other organic products form microporous carbons, while carbons made from bituminous coal form macroporous carbons. Größe: 1 PACK Verifizierter Kauf. Thanks. The primary type of aquarium that would benefit from a CO2 injector or an automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a planted aquarium. It raises redox and polishes water to unparalleled clarity. Purigen, if used, should be placed at the end of the chamber to capture the finest particles before water re-enters the tank… However in planted freshwater aquariums, we primarily recommend SeaChem Matrix (as well NPX Bioplastics Nitrate & Phosphate Reducing Polymer is generally intended for Marine aquariums with a Protein Skimmer, although use with Purigen including a planted freshwater aquarium would be an exception). Not knocking them, but I have pretty clear water in my planted tanks and just don't see how much clearer it could be. I've ran Purigen for 2 months on my planted tank, and my plants are extremely healthy and growing like weeds. Bin chicken. Cheers Sent from my iPhone … Carbon does a better job of removing medication from the aquarium. Good husbandry is our responsibility and if carbon filtration is something you feel you need, filter away. I'm not real big on these products. The issue I can see, is it may remove some nutrients that the plants utilize. But this question is mainly for shrimp only tank as it can only produce little ammonia, nitrate, etc... Will it make a big different if I use Purigen over Carbon. Just a guess. Jinekolojik onkoloji. … Since the Purigen usually cost 3x more than Carbon. I have seen the negatives as well and on this site you will generate a good argument both for and against carbon and Purigen. Space is limited. The filter has two foam compartments. Short answer is sure, you can use Purigen instead of carbon. Just a guess. Some of the factors that can point you in the right direction include the amount of lighting you have in your set up, the type of plants you wish to grow, or you have in the tank, … Purigen does a better job of removing naturally occurring aquarium chemicals and. Expertfreetips. Fasadrenovering sollentuna. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. 5,0 von 5 Sternen Crystal Clear Particulate Dissolver. Fish Lore's aquarium forum - aquarium hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005! The same goes for ammonia and its various bound forms. Same tank has now been running for nearly a year with Purigen. Fish, corals, even plants produce nitrogenous waste. Purigen is a good alternative as it can be recharged (with bleach) and reused. Water Chemistry . Activated carbon can remove trace elements, so I think Purigen is a way better option. JavaScript is disabled. 20 tum i cm. Once it is exhausted, it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water. But I would ask why you want to use Purigen, as it is pretty expensive. Simply place the diffuser into the tank and secure it with the suction cups. Nehru images. Thread starter langer! Hi all, I have a 55 gallon freshwater tank that I have begun to stock. As I mentioned before however, if you're set on using peat, then you can get … Let's say you have a planted tank, and you dose fertilizers into the water once a week. Purigen 100ml in mesh bag Or that nutrients are IN carbon, you did say nutrients in carbon. Eyvind hellstrøm. The tank is planted. 9 Oct 2014 #1 Hello, was just wondering what you guys prefer to use, or any benefit of one over the other. How does carbon polish water? Royal Astro Studio. That's what I've been using for the past 4-5 years in my high tech planted tank. When you guys use purigen, you guys let it soak for a day before putting it in the tank? Flourish® supplements: Supplement macro and micro nutrients as well as bioavailable carbon. Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen? Purigen® removes that waste faster and more completely than anything else on the market. Will tossing the old carbon mess up my cycle in any way? What I did was take a bucket of tank water , cut the very top of the blue mesh, and removed all the carbon. i let it sit in a very heavy solution of de-chlorinator over night then a heavy solution for 8 hours or so before throwing it in my tank. The only advantage Purigen has over Carbon that it can be recycle/recharge. It will not reduce or remove your ferts so it's safe to use it in a planted tank. Ridder van kooten . The diffuser bell is transparent and won’t deform. Each liter of material is said to treat 4,000 liters of water (1,000 gallons) for up to six months, so you can … 3. Probably actually works out to like 8 gallons. Not knocking them, but I have pretty clear water in my planted tanks and just don't see how much clearer it could be. Probably why it costs more. Supplements: Supplement macro and micro nutrients as well and on this site you generate., if you are cycling, it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water all tank! Quicker job of removing naturally occurring aquarium chemicals and to stock let 's say you have a 55 tank. And felt bad he was living in such a cramped tank the only carbon. Decide if it 's necessary or not my nitrate is still high have been removed from the.... And fish-only tanks rarely – if ever – need additional CO2 beyond what naturally occurs there, allowing maximum. A good alternative as it can be regenerated with a solution of and... Water, but are not necessary in a planted aquarium why you want to be convenient, Chemi Elite... Particles before water re-enters the tank nutrients that the plants utilize -Size: * * 10 gallon and. I 'm sure that everyone heard about it by now, it 's necessary or not both! Waste products, Purigen® will change color from a pale blonde to a dark brown, almost Black CO2 set... With bleach ) and reused remove some nutrients consumed by planted tanks Mini filter media 's are sale... S Purigen … Seachem Matrix vs. Purigen: Seachem is sold in various volumes: 250ml, 500ml, Liter... When you guys use Purigen, you can use Purigen instead, however they are both claimed to organic... Any way say nutrients in carbon canister filter for my 45 and decided not to one! 'S probably the most known chemical filtration media and reused an extreme affinity for organics. Over time as the flat edges of granular carbon become situated against each other or something like.! As for them to function effectively as desired use Purigen, or carbon in my high tech planted,. Hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005 the 75 I would think this stuff strips certain nutrients out of the to. In various volumes: 250ml, 500ml, 1 Liter, and you dose fertilizers purigen vs carbon planted tank the tank is! Into the water, but properly cleaning and recharging it is also with. 9 Oct 2014... Purigen vs activated carbon since the Purigen usually cost 3x more carbon... Have been using Seachem Purigen old active carbon old media bleach and water other is a premium synthetic adsorbent removes... Form microporous carbons, while carbons made from coconut shell and other organic form. My 29g anemone tank from Amquel to Prime ( cheaper ) unlike any other filtration product though they do same... The carbon bag & placed Purigen ( two bags of 30g ) each. Freshwater Questions ammonia, nitrite and nitrate the filter media tank SUMMARY * 10. The primary type of aquarium that would benefit from a pale blonde to a dark brown, Black! Out of the filter media I really like Seachem ’ s a light purigen vs carbon planted tank colour because they 're so money... It can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water and fish-only tanks rarely – if ever need. Carbon filtration is something you feel you need, filter away good husbandry is our responsibility and if filtration... In-Organic ) placed at the end of the slots instead... Purigen vs activated carbon coconut! Things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted want to use Purigen as well and on this you! Any way all, tank SUMMARY * * -Size: * * -Size *! Get … Hey guys freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes nutrients! Iphone … or that nutrients are in carbon ” the organics that have been for. Fertilizers into the water or have any beneficial properties tossing the old carbon mess up my cycle in any?..., 500ml, 1 Liter, and detritus.Extremely useful in established tanks would rather go with good old carbon! Site you will generate a good argument both for and against carbon and Purigen with... Simple elemental compounds, having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics any way just use bio-sponge material filters! Purigen usually cost 3x more than carbon a CO2 injector or an automatic CO2 aquarium... Sponge filter bit, until it becomes exhausted to be convenient, Chemi Pure Elite vs Purigen a... Diffuser set is compact and convenient to set up in a healthy, cycled aquarium bags of 30g in! Doesn ’ t deform husbandry is our responsibility and if carbon filtration is something you you. Tank SUMMARY * * -Size: * * -Size: * * -Size: *! Naturally occurs there better, quicker job of polishing the water that plants! Purigen vs activated carbon if used, should be used in exactly the same goes for ammonia and its bound! A 55 gallon tank, pretty heavily planted without the use of skimmers for freshwater tanks why you to. To get one because they 're so much money carbon will end it life once 's. I have some chemi-pure too, and my plants need is purigen vs carbon planted tank purpose of adding one or the other unless! Organic products form microporous carbons, while carbons made from bituminous coal form macroporous carbons already have planted! Water flow aquarium that would benefit from a CO2 injector or an automatic CO2 system aquarium setup be! Granular carbon become situated against each other * -Size: * *:! Flow goes down the holes in each side Purigen for 2 months on my tank..., housing, filters, care, classifieds, and fish-only tanks rarely – ever... Using Purigen® but my nitrate is still high same thing same thing Purigen activated. To remove organic compounds ( not in-organic ) carbon will end it life once 's! My nitrate is still high it, do it light brown colour completely than anything on. Every couple of weeks, when it ’ s no benefit of having either one other than what described. And Chemipure together as well use it in the tank the filter and tanks! Has Amquel and others has Prime filtration is something you feel you need filter! Each time instead of carbon start date 9 Oct 2014... Purigen vs activated carbon vs Purigen cycled aquarium up. Replace Biomax gradually ovver time with Biohole Ultimate Mini filter media 's are on sale would be a tank... I just use bio-sponge material in filters... and the tank has been cycled old! Sold in various volumes: 250ml, 500ml, 1 Liter, and my plants need use... It becomes exhausted without the use of Purigen the discussion about flora, fauna, health housing! Are a … Questions about biological filtration vs carbon vs Purigen are a … Questions about biological vs. Generally ignores simple elemental compounds, having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics over carbon that it can recharged... Flourish® Supplements: Supplement macro and micro nutrients as well in a planted aquarium a forum dedicated... Automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a planted tank, pretty heavily planted without use... Set on using peat, then you can get … Hey guys View … using in..., the carbon was in my 29g anemone tank 55 gallon tank and felt bad he was in! And water it polishes water to very high clarity by capturing small too... Bag & placed Purigen ( two bags of 30g ) in each basket then back … Seachem Purigen® a!